Previously, El Tejano reported details about Judge Banales' September 28 order tossing a murder conviction. He ordered a new trial. He wrote that the evidence at trial did not support the verdict.

Read that story here: https://www.eltejanorgv.com/judge-tosses-freer-murder-verdict-over-weak-proof-and-fingerprint-records-da-fights-back/

The DA's office is appealing. It says it has also asked the Court of Appeals to keep the defendant in custody during the appeal.

Prosecutors however painted a different picture during trial which is at odds with Banales' order. Prosecutors presented evidence that Luis Daniel Rodriguez was on a cocaine binge for 48 hours or more before Denise Godsey Decoteau was killed. Rodriguez bought mostly from the man Decoteau delivered for. Rodriguez ran out of cash and bought on credit. Rodriguez apparently used an application (Text Now) to order cocaine from a different number.

The judge's order does not mention texts or that app. It says he "contacted her by cell phone." A Ranger went through his phone by hand and apparently "found nothing of interest," the order says. His first phone was damaged and destroyed.

Prosecutors said Rodriguez texted Decoteau less than half an hour before she died. They also stated Rodriguez ordered cocaine and said he would leave the money on the windowsill. Prosecutors indicate that no witness ever mentioned an envelope. The order however, says the evidence showed cash was left in an envelope.

During the trial, prosecutors presented evidence that Decoteau went to Rodriguez's house but made no drop. Decoteau texted and asked if Rodriguez would leave the money or not. About 15 minutes before she died, Decoteau texted that she was calling it a night. Soon after, she said she could still deliver. Prosecutors said Rodriguez agreed.

Prosecutors say two people saw Decoteau alone earlier. Decoteau was ready to go home. It was her birthday. The order puts the events at around 5 to 6 a.m. on April 9, 2021.

Prosecutors indicated that GPS data from the SUV showed a stop at Rodriguez's home about five minutes before Decoteau was killed. Then the SUV travelled fast to where her body was found. The order says a deputy told the jury about On-Star tracking. However, the system "cannot state who was in the vehicle as it traveled."

Witnesses testified the SUV was found still running about two blocks from her body. According to experts, Rodriguez's DNA was found on the steering wheel. The order says a lab expert could not rule Rodriguez out. That however is not the same as a match. The order says other testimony found none of his DNA on the wheel. It also says Rodriguez did not admit driving the SUV.

Prosecutors said a camera filmed one person walking fast from the SUV in the direction of Rodriguez's home, three blocks away. The order says the image was "very grainy" and no one could be identified.

Prosecutors argued that within three minutes of the killing, Rodriguez texted the man Decoteau delivered for. Rodriguez said she never showed up. Prosecutors argued that Rodriguez erased his texts with Decoteau. A few days later, Rodriguez got rid of his old phone and bought a new one.

Testimony showed that Rodriguez was not in custody. Rodriguez denied seeing Decoteau at all. A cut was visible on Rodriguez's finger. Rodriguez said his finger was cut while working with his father. Prosecutors said Rodriguez had not worked with his father.

Evidence showed that Rodriguez left town early the following year and police obtained a warrant. The order adds more. It says Rodriguez went to Nebraska. Rodriguez's daughter died in May 2022. Rodriguez came back to Texas to see his daughter's tombstone and to surrender, the order says. Bee County deputies stopped Rodriguez on June 14, 2022.

Prosecutors said that after his arrest, Rodriguez first denied seeing Decoteau or getting in the SUV. Later, they say, Rodriguez said he did get in. Rodriguez said two big men with tattoos were in the SUV. Rodriguez said they offered him a quarter ounce of cocaine to help with a delivery. Rodriguez said they began attacking Decoteau soon after. Rodriguez said he thought it was a "hit." Rodriguez could not name the men. Rodriguez said they were not from Freer.

Prosecutors argued that no one picks up a witness before a murder hit. The order says a Ranger confirmed that only Rodriguez and Decoteau were in the SUV. It does not say how. The order says Rodriguez's second story did not fully match his first. It also says Rodriguez told a Ranger the men said he was next.

The judge also wrote that a 2024 lab report ruled out Rodriguez's DNA on the knife handle. One unknown person handled the knife. No fingerprints matched Rodriguez. A Ranger testified that missing DNA did not clear him. The judge found the defense never got fingerprint records it could use. He wrote that Rodriguez was "deprived of a fair trial."

The DA's office said it is confident the jury's verdict will be upheld. The order kept bail at $1 million. Rodriguez remains in custody.