A federal judge in McAllen has ruled for a man accused of smuggling $219,500 in cash. On Wednesday, Nov. 18, Chief Judge Randy Crane granted a motion to suppress evidence in the case of Eden Rodriguez.
A motion to suppress asks a judge to keep evidence out of a trial. Court records show the judge found on Monday, Nov. 16, that there was no probable cause for the traffic stop. That means the judge found the stop did not have enough legal support.
At that hearing, the judge set more briefing on a key question. Could the evidence still be used because Rodriguez agreed to a search? On Nov. 18, after arguments, the court granted the motion.
The docket does not say which evidence is now out. It does not say why the judge ruled the way he did. It does not say what prosecutors will do next.
Rodriguez asked for bond. The government said no. The judge will send the bond question to the duty magistrate judge for a new look. Rodriguez was sent back to the custody of the U.S. Marshals.
Here is what the complaint says. A DEA special agent filed it on April 6. It says a Wharton County deputy saw a white Audi SUV on Highway 59 on April 3, around noon. The SUV was going south, just north of the Jackson County line.
The complaint says a dealer tag covered a large part of the word Texas on the front plate. It says that made the plate unreadable. It says the rear plate also had a dealer cover that partly blocked it.
The deputy stopped the SUV. The complaint says the driver was Rodriguez and a woman was the passenger. It says Rodriguez seemed nervous even after he heard he would only get a warning. It says both of them agreed to a search.
The deputy says he saw tool marks around bolts on the rear door panels. He says he looked inside with a scope and saw wrapped bundles. The complaint says the bundles held wads of cash, rubber banded in different bills and wrapped in duct tape.
The complaint also describes what Rodriguez said. It says that at the sheriff's office, a sergeant talked to him in Spanish after reading him his rights. It says he said he picked up the money from a man he did not know in Houston. It says he said he was paid $5,000 to take it to Mexico. It says he said his wife knew nothing about it.
The sheriff's office counted $219,500, the complaint says. The docket does not say if that statement is now barred too.
The defense says the plate could be read. On Nov. 12, defense lawyer Michael J. Garza filed a proffer. A proffer is a summary of what a witness would say. It says a passenger from the stop would testify that on April 15 she and her son picked up the SUV from the Wharton County impound lot. It says they filmed it at a travel center in Wharton.
The filing says the 52 second video shows the front plate clearly, with the word TEXAS and the plate number. It says the dealer frame does not cover the state name or any letter or number. The defense says that goes against the complaint.
Rodriguez was arrested on April 7 in Rio Grande City. A grand jury indicted him on April 28. The indictment has one count. It says he hid $219,500 and tried to take it from Houston to Mexico to avoid a cash reporting rule. He pleaded not guilty on May 4, through a waiver.
A magistrate judge allowed bond on April 15. A district judge stopped his release the same day. On May 15, a judge ordered him held until trial.
Court records also show a separate federal case in McAllen against Eden Rodriguez Jr. A complaint was filed on Nov. 9. The docket lists the charge as "bringing in and harboring aliens."
He first went to court on Nov. 10. He gave up a preliminary hearing, and the judge found probable cause. The court gave him a lawyer. At a detention hearing on Nov. 12, the judge said he would rule later. He is in the custody of the U.S. Marshals.
The complaint El Tejano reviewed does not say what he is accused of doing. The records do not say how the two cases are connected.
Everyone is presumed innocent until proved otherwise.