He called 911 and said his friend had shown up at his door, bloody and stabbed in the chest. Police later said the facts did not match his story.
Now Israel Anthony Cortez, 28, is going to prison for 40 years.
A Bexar County jury found Cortez guilty of manslaughter on Monday, Sept. 28. The case was about the 2023 death of his friend, Robert Neaves. The same jury set his sentence.
Cortez was first charged with murder. The jury chose a lesser charge instead.
That may sound like a break. It was not. Here is why.
In Texas, manslaughter is a second-degree felony. Most of the time, that means 2 to 20 years in prison. But Cortez got 40.
The Bexar County District Attorney's Office said Cortez faced a higher range of punishment. Prosecutors said he is a repeat offender. They also said he is a member of a criminal street gang. Texas law lets a jury give a tougher sentence to a person with an earlier felony conviction. That higher range let the jury go past the usual 20-year top.
Judge Stephanie Boyd was in charge of the trial in the 187th District Court, officials said.
District Attorney Joe Gonzales spoke after the sentence.
"This sentence holds Israel Anthony Cortez accountable for the death of Robert Neaves," Gonzales said. "While no sentence can undo the loss experienced by Mr. Neaves' loved ones, accountability is an important part of the pursuit of justice."
The case goes back to Sept. 14, 2023.
That morning, Cortez called 911. He said Neaves had been hurt in a fight somewhere else. He said Neaves then showed up at his home on the Far Southeast Side of San Antonio. He said Neaves had a stab wound to the chest and injuries to his face.
Police came. They found Neaves with a stab wound to his chest. He was taken to a hospital. He died there.
At first, Cortez told police the same story he told 911. Police let him go home. He also said he had not been with Neaves before he showed up hurt.
Then the story started to fall apart.
That evening and the next day, two people called police. Both said Cortez told them he stabbed Neaves during a fight.
One of them was his own mother. She told police her son confessed to her.
The other person said Cortez called the stabbing an accident.
Police also got a search warrant for the house. An arrest warrant affidavit says officers found two knives. One had what looked like blood on the blade.
A neighbor told police something else. The neighbor said Cortez and Neaves were drinking beer outside the house at 3 a.m. that day. The neighbor said the two men pulled up in a car at 7 a.m. That was about 30 minutes before the 911 call, the affidavit says.
An arrest report also said video showed Cortez picking up Neaves hours before the stabbing. That did not match what Cortez told police.
A judge signed a warrant for his arrest on Sept. 29, 2023. He was arrested in early October 2023. His bond was set at $200,000.
So why manslaughter and not murder?
In Texas, murder means killing someone on purpose. It can also mean trying to badly hurt someone in a way that could kill, and they die. Manslaughter is different. It means causing a death by being reckless.
By picking manslaughter, the jury found that Cortez caused his friend's death by being reckless. It did not convict him of murder. The DA's statement did not say what Cortez's lawyers argued at trial.
The jury's decision does not change one fact. Robert Neaves is gone. He was stabbed in the chest. His friend called 911 with a story that the arrest report says did not match the video.
Cortez can still appeal.
For now, he heads to state prison for 40 years.