This is an update to a story El Tejano reported on October 5. https://www.eltejanorgv.com/trial-opens-in-killing-of-san-benito-officer-the-state-wants-death/
A jury in Cameron County has found Rogelio Martinez Jr. guilty of capital murder. The case is the killing of San Benito Police Lt. Milton Resendez. Resendez was shot during a police chase in 2023.
Both sides made their last pitch Thursday morning. Then the jurors went behind closed doors. They talked it over for more than four hours. Then they came back with the verdict.
The state is seeking the death penalty.
Now the trial moves to a new part. It is called the punishment phase. It will decide his sentence. It will be death, or life in prison with no parole.
Resendez was 54. He was the first San Benito police officer ever killed on duty. He was a cop for more than 30 years.
The case goes back to October 17, 2023. A county park officer stopped a pickup on the beach at South Padre Island. The stop was for speeding. The truck took off. Officers chased it through Port Isabel and into Brownsville.
Hours later, officers found two men in another vehicle. A second chase began. It went all the way to San Benito.
Resendez joined that chase. Gunfire came through the driver's side of his patrol car. He was hit. He was taken to a hospital, where he died.
Martinez was 18 at the time. He is from Brownsville. He pleaded not guilty.
Prosecutors said Martinez knew he was shooting at a police officer. They pointed to a taped talk he had with the officers who worked the case. Prosecutors said he admitted in it that he shot at officers. They told the jury he was close enough to see Resendez. They said he was close enough to know Resendez was a cop.
The defense told a different story. Martinez's lawyers said there was reasonable doubt about who fired the deadly shot.
They pointed to the other man in the case. His name is Rodrigo Axel Espinosa Valdez. He has been named as the driver. He pleaded guilty before trial to a lesser charge of murder. Before the trial began, he was expected to testify.
He was never called to testify. Martinez's lawyers asked why. They also pointed to DNA. They said it tied Espinosa Valdez to the gun named as the murder weapon.
The defense said Martinez never meant to kill anyone. They said the state did not prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.
The jury found him guilty.
This trial took a long time to get here. Jury picking began in August. It took weeks. Twelve jurors and three backups were picked in September. Witnesses began Monday, October 5.
Luis Saenz is the Cameron County DA. He spoke at a vigil soon after Resendez died. He warned that no case is a sure thing.
"There are good cases, and there are weak cases, but there's no such thing as an open-and-shut case," Saenz said at the time.
Resendez grew up in San Benito. He graduated from San Benito High School in 1987. He worked for police in Brownsville and Palm Valley. He worked for the school district police, too. Then he joined the San Benito police. He left behind his wife, Melissa.
The punishment phase comes next. El Tejano will keep following this case.